Files
openclaw-dnd-city-visualiza…/references/effort-tiers.md
T

5.7 KiB

Render effort tiers

Status: newly adopted (October 2026) and on trial. The scheme below was agreed for the next major town batch and is being evaluated there. Everything in it is a proposal with reasons, not a law. Use it, measure it, and adjust the numbers to your own table, budget and renderer.

The one test

Tier = the probability that the place comes into focus at the table.

Not its size, not its importance in the world, not how pretty it would be. A third-rate pub that the storyline sends the party to is tier 1. A master weaponsmith in a town the party only passes through is tier 3. The categories below are examples of where places usually land, never rules.

Tier Meaning Typically Render deliverables Budget (one hosted edit model, 2026 prices)
1 Guaranteed to come into focus town overviews and approaches; the party's base, inn or hall; the storyline's buildings; the guild's tavern block model + aerial and approach plates; the full time x weather matrix; every room the party will stand in; scene beats; named staff as reusable anchor characters ~100-200 renders, ~$10-20
2 Likely adventuring shops (gold, gems, weapons, armor, alchemist, healer); civic and sacred landmarks (temple, moot hall, gates, market, docks) exterior A/B day + night + one snow; one counter interior; the proprietor as a scene character; goods at the wealth tier; a price list ~20-40 renders, ~$2-4
3 Possible third-rate pubs, mundane townsfolk shops one exterior day, one interior, a keeper from the pool ~5-10 renders, under $1
4 Unlikely / background everything else on the map a name, a tagline, one line of text, maybe a sign emblem no renders

Special-case venues may warrant their own budget regardless of tier; decide that per campaign.

Deliverables per tier, spelled out

Tier 1

  • Geometry: block model of the site in its town context; template plates for every camera (approach, aerial, entrance, interior rooms).
  • Exterior matrix: Day / Sunset / Night x Dry / Rain / Snow (light) for the A and B cameras (18 frames), plus whatever storm and deep-snow cells your calendar needs (references/matrices.md).
  • Interiors: every room the party will stand in, as an empty master (people-free, so it stays reusable as a plate).
  • Population x time matrix (venues with people): 4 x 3, Morning / Afternoon / Evening / Late Night x Quiet / Moderate / Packed, from one "reveal from the door" camera (12 frames). A 4 x 4 with an Empty column only for storyline hubs where an empty room is itself a scene (16 frames).
  • Scenes: the beats the story needs, on the canon rooms with the canon faces.
  • Named staff as reusable characters with locked faces.

Tier 2

  • Exterior A and B: Day Dry, Night Dry, one Snow (light).
  • One counter interior, empty master.
  • The proprietor as a scene character (a face that recurs, not a full anchor pack).
  • Goods rendered at the wealth tier; a price list in text.
  • Population matrix 2 x 3: Day / Sunset x Quiet / Moderate / Packed (6 frames), for any venue with a counter or benches.

Tier 3

  • One exterior, Day Dry. One interior. A keeper drawn from the generic pool.
  • Population matrix 1 x 2: its peak hour x Quiet / Packed (2 frames).

Tier 4

  • Text only: name, tagline, one line. A sign emblem if it is cheap. No renders.

Model-cost tiering (which agent does what)

Image QA is the real token cost, not the renders. So the agent that executes a tier is sized to the tier:

Tier Planning Execution Review
1 the most capable model writes the brief and reads the report a mid-sized model runs the lane a short review by the capable model
2 brief from a template mid-sized model none beyond the lane's own gates
3 template a small model none
4 — a local or text-only model (it never has to see an image) none

Canon guard for lanes run by smaller models: every brief says "anything not in this brief is marked PROPOSED". A lane invents less when it knows invention is allowed but must be labeled. (The "no glass anywhere" rule that haunted one campaign for a week was a lane's invention; see references/prompting.md on glass.)

Rules

  • Play promotes, never demote. A place the players actually enter moves up a tier for the next session. Nothing rendered is ever deleted; superseded files are moved aside.
  • Per-tier ceiling. A lane may not exceed its tier's budget without the GM's say-so. Cap retakes and the number of images reviewed, not just renders.
  • Attention is the scarcest resource, then tokens, then wattage. Tier budgets cap tokens and renders, but never by pushing review load onto the human: spend more on self-gating so fewer, better frames reach them.
  • Canon-direct delivery. Work that passes its own gates goes straight into the campaign's canon folder with a one-line note. A human review entry is reserved for: the face of a story-critical character; a human gate before something permanent (a model fine-tune, a bake); something the GM asked to see. Reviewed means done: review remarks are records, not new work orders.
  • Renderer policy is unchanged by tier. Cut spend by volume (fewer takes, re-roll caps, tighter candidate sets), never by switching to a weaker renderer for the cheap tiers. A weaker renderer costs more in retakes and review.

What to evaluate after the trial

  • Did the smaller-model lanes invent canon? How often?
  • Retake rate per tier compared with capable-model lanes.
  • Actual tokens and renders per tier against the budget.
  • Did the tiering match what the table actually visited? (That is the only question that matters.)