# BCH Node vs Hosted API — Evaluation & Recommendation _Spike task: PRO-61 | Evaluated: 2026-05-17 | Revised: 2026-05-17 (self-hosted infra constraint)_ --- ## Overview Two primary paths exist to access Bitcoin Cash on-chain data: | | Option A: Self-Hosted Node | Option B: Hosted API | |---|---|---| | **Software** | BCHN v29.0.0 + Fulcrum | Fullstack.cash / GetBlock.io / Tatum | | **Time to first data** | 12–48 hours (initial sync) | Minutes | | **Spike cost** | $0 marginal (own hardware) | $0–15/month | | **Production cost** | ~$0 marginal (own hardware) | $15–100/month | | **Rate limits** | None | Tier-dependent | | **Reliability** | Self-managed | Provider SLA | | **Data completeness** | Full | Full (indexer-dependent) | | **Ops burden** | Medium | Low | --- ## Option A: Self-Hosted BCH Full Node (BCHN) ### What is BCHN? [Bitcoin Cash Node (BCHN)](https://bitcoincashnode.org) is the reference implementation for the BCH network. v29.0.0 (released May 2026) implements the May 2026 network upgrade. ### Technical Requirements (May 2026) The full stack is BCHN (full node) + Fulcrum (high-performance ElectrumX implementation for xpub indexing). | Resource | BCHN minimum | BCHN + Fulcrum recommended | |---|---|---| | **Blockchain size** | 222 GB (growing ~30 GB/year) | — | | **Fulcrum index size** | — | ~100–150 GB additional | | **Storage total** | 280 GB | **400–500 GB SSD** | | **RAM** | 4 GB | **8 GB** (Fulcrum uses 2–4 GB during sync) | | **CPU** | 2 cores | **4 cores** (Fulcrum parallelises index build) | | **Network** | 50 KB/s sustained | 10 Mbps broadband | | **Initial sync** | 12–48 hours (BCHN) | +4–20 hours (Fulcrum index) | **Minimum viable hardware for own infrastructure:** Any server with 4 cores, 8 GB RAM, and 500 GB SSD (or HDD + SSD hybrid with the Fulcrum DB on SSD) will run this stack comfortably. ### Operational Cost on Own Hardware No VPS line item. Marginal cost is limited to: | Item | Estimate | Notes | |---|---|---| | **Bandwidth** | ~2–5 GB/month | BCH blocks average ≪ 1 MB; p2p + peer propagation is light | | **Power (dedicated server)** | $3–7/month | ~30–80W × 720h × $0.12/kWh; $0 if server already runs | | **Storage expansion** (if needed) | $20–60 one-time | 500 GB SSD if not already available | | **Ongoing marginal cost** | **~$0–7/month** | Within existing infra envelope | BCH is dramatically lighter on bandwidth than Bitcoin (~2–5 GB/month vs. ~400 GB/month for BTC) because BCH blocks rarely exceed 200 KB in practice despite the 32 MB cap. ### Pros - No rate limits; unlimited queries - Full blockchain data including mempool - Complete indexing control (xpub watch, custom filters) - No third-party dependency or recurring SaaS cost - Privacy — no external API traffic logging - Near-zero marginal cost on existing owned hardware ### Cons - 12–48 hour initial BCHN sync + 4–20 hour Fulcrum index blocks development start - Must monitor node health and apply network upgrades (e.g., May 2026 upgrade) - Storage grows ~30 GB/year; plan capacity for Fulcrum index growth too - Ops responsibility is internal (vs. provider SLA) --- ## Option B: Hosted Public API ### Providers Evaluated #### 1. Fullstack.cash ⭐ Recommended for spike - **URL:** https://fullstack.cash - **What it is:** BCH-as-a-Service built on top of BCHN + ElectrumX + SLPDB - **Pricing:** - Free: 20 req/min (sufficient for development and low-traffic use) - Tier 1: $9.99–14.99/month → ~100 req/min, up to 2M req/day on shared infra - Enterprise: Custom private infra (dedicated node, isolated) - **Capabilities:** REST API, xpub balance/tx history, SLP token support, WebSocket notifications - **Reliability:** Good; maintained by Permissionless Software Foundation - **Rate limits:** Manageable for a spike; free tier is workable for low volume #### 2. GetBlock.io - **URL:** https://getblock.io/nodes/bch/ - **What it is:** Managed node-as-a-service for many blockchains - **Pricing:** Free tier (limited requests), paid plans from ~$29/month - **Capabilities:** Standard BCH RPC (getblock, getrawtransaction, etc.) - **Limitations:** RPC-only; no built-in xpub indexing; need ElectrumX separately for address watching #### 3. Tatum.io - **URL:** https://tatum.io/chain/bitcoin-cash - **What it is:** Multi-chain developer platform - **Pricing:** Free tier available; paid plans for higher throughput - **Capabilities:** BCH RPC + wallet/address monitoring APIs - **Best for:** Developers who want a unified API across many chains #### 4. Mainnet.cash - **URL:** https://mainnet.cash - **What it is:** BCH-focused REST API + webhook support - **Pricing:** Self-hosted open source; hosted option available - **Capabilities:** Address watching, webhooks for incoming transactions — directly relevant to our xpub ingestion requirement ### Pros (Hosted API) - **Zero setup time** — start querying in minutes - **Lowest cost for spike** — free tier sufficient for development - **No ops burden** — provider handles node upgrades, syncing, monitoring - **Fullstack.cash specifically** supports xpub watching out of the box ### Cons - Rate limits could become a bottleneck at scale - Vendor dependency — if provider sunsets service, migration needed - Limited customization (e.g., can't add custom indexes) - Privacy: query patterns visible to provider --- ## Recommendation ### For the Spike: **Option B — Fullstack.cash (free tier)** Start with Fullstack.cash free tier for the spike. Rationale: 1. **Speed**: Development starts in minutes, not 12–48 hours for node sync. 2. **Cost**: $0 during spike — no hardware provisioning needed. 3. **xpub support**: Fullstack.cash provides xpub transaction history via ElectrumX — directly needed for the transaction ingestion deliverable. 4. **Low risk for 2-week spike**: 20 req/min is fine for functional testing. ### For Production: **Option A — Self-Hosted BCHN + Fulcrum on Own Infrastructure** Board has confirmed that we operate significant own infrastructure and should not use cloud/VPS providers for compute. Self-hosted is both the preferred and most cost-effective path for production: 1. **No rate limits** — critical for payment monitoring at scale. 2. **Near-zero marginal cost** — existing hardware; only incremental storage (~$0–60 one-time) and bandwidth (~2–5 GB/month, well within any broadband quota). 3. **Full control** — no vendor dependency, no data leakage to third-party APIs. 4. **Auditability** — complete on-chain data locally. **Minimum viable hardware:** 4 cores, 8 GB RAM, 500 GB SSD. Any server meeting this threshold can run BCHN + Fulcrum. --- ## Migration Path ``` Spike (week 1-2) → Production (own hardware) Fullstack.cash free tier BCHN + Fulcrum on own infra $0/month ~$0/month marginal (one-time: 500 GB SSD if needed) ```