Files

8.1 KiB

Failure modes and the fix that worked

Quick index. Each line: the symptom, the measured cause, the fix. Longer versions live in prompting.md, gates.md and matrices.md.

Geometry

symptom cause fix
overview invents halls, towers, a church at town scale each house is a few px; the plate barely constrains the renderer invented-structure gate; closer camera; name the absent big things in the town block
wide view zoomed in 4-10 % the renderer frames for legibility FRAMING LOCK with band positions in % of frame
small town moved up toward the mountains behind a wide foreground same the explicit FOREGROUND sentence ("the town is SMALL and sits LOW, houses from 71 % to 96 %")
facade cropped by the plate restored to full height, with the tower the renderer steps back to show the building "every edge cuts the scene where image 1's edges cut it; the set-back story and tower are hidden from here" (0/3 -> 4/4)
castle redrawn as a palace at 3 km prior for "castle" landmark region correlation (0.16 vs 0.4-0.7) + "the castle stays small, not enlarged into a palace; no new towers, spires or domes"
mountain shrunk to fit its summit in frame the plate's wall runs out the top edge SKY_FIT column gate + "rises out of the top edge, no sky above them there"
snow on a low flank through a telephoto prior for "alpine" one edit-with-itself replacing white patches with rock; gate on snow-colored px below the snow line
verticals tilted 1-2.6 degrees, frame shrunk a pitched-up plate render level with a vertical lens shift
a feature on the wrong face named in a shared feature list while occluded from this camera per-camera visibility list; disown occluded features positively
a river or castle appears in a view facing away from it the prompt's global landmark text "there is NO river, NO lake, NO castle; they are behind the camera"
eleven gables where the map has four houses touching quads in the massing 4-7 px gaps, stepped fronts
ruins in the plate footprint slivers open with a 2 m disc, drop pieces under 40 m2
a stone post with a ball finial by the road a mannequin cut by the frame edge proxies 10 m or more from the camera, off the edge
battlements across a roof convex split of an L-wing with merlons on the internal seam fix the edge list; check the untextured plate
a quay or wall runs to the frame edge the model never said where it ends model the far side as a different surface
a false lake beside the town river class from a blurred floor level take the river from the terrain's own water mask
the road in a trench the road layer cut below grade a broad shelf on a 1 m layer
a gate hidden in its own wall's shadow the hour chosen for the plate move the sun (16:00 instead of 16:30) and name the hour in the prompt

People

symptom cause fix
aerial figures 2.4-5 m tall nobody set their size; the renderer sizes for legibility proxies in the plate; the figure-bracket gate; shrink-in-place for legacy sets
near walkers +25-28 % eye-level camera with no horizon relation the EYELINE clause (eyes on the horizon line)
giants at a gate no nearest-object relation SIZES BY THE NEAREST OBJECT (adults reach half the palisade, a third of the posts)
a 1 m character at 1.4 m a stated size is ignored a contact relation the renderer has to draw (a hand flat on his hood, arm straight down)
extra lantern-carriers at night the noun "lantern" HEADCOUNT lock, lanterns carried by the same people
ghosts on quays and stair posts "steam vents" drop the steam clause
guests on the shut terrace "2-3 guests on the balcony"; the noun beats the negation state where everyone is as a positive fact; repeat the untrodden snow
a busy room with backs to the lens packed density fills the foreground NEAR-FOREGROUND and LOWER-RIGHT locks
a referenced man drawn twice face reference + "lying" exact headcount; "appears exactly ONCE ... the corner is EMPTY"
an outfit sheet's cowl on the wrong woman a sheet attached without its wearer's face describe the garment in prose; "she has NO brow ornament"
modern waistcoats, derbies, riveted aprons "prosperous" + a plain garment noun the period cut as construction facts; forbid the modern modes by name; a women's clause with no trousers
hip flips on side gear "on the viewer's right" "on HER own right hip" + "the back view is the same person turned round" (0 flips)
bloomers under a shift the men's trouser clause reused on a woman a women's clause: "hangs straight from the belt; lower legs bare"
a V sign "two fingers raised" drop the gesture; "no hand sign"
field sheds become people in deep snow "tiny dark upright marks = townspeople" a lock naming the sheds; eye-check open fields at 2x

Surfaces and weather

symptom cause fix
snow cell fails the gate 18/18 a snow cap raises every surface ~4 px thin fall "no deeper than a finger" for the calm cell; wall-band gate for storms
storm cells show a dusting the thin-fall clause reused storm prompt names snow in the air, loads, cornices, drifts; legibility clause outranks the storm
night heavy blizzard reads as a dark soft frame wording cannot push a clear plate to a whiteout; contrast metrics misrank veil-before-edit (deterministic veil from the depth plate), then "IMAGE 1 ALREADY SHOWS THE STORM AT FULL STRENGTH; keep visibility as low or lower"; silhouette gate
summer edit of a winter keeper adds ponds, drains channels, adds bridges snowy low ground and snow-banked water look alike pixel or guide lock; or build summer keepers from a summer plate; review water at 1-2x
a bright sunset glow in the east the sky in frame is east; the sun is behind the camera "THE SKY IN THIS PICTURE IS THE EASTERN SKY ... NO glow"
a sun disc in frame the prompt named the sun without its position "the sun is behind the camera; no sun disc"
a smoke plume from a building with no hearth "chimney smoke rises" a no-smoke clause for that building
the bar counter survives the "shut" state "no counter" "under the roof there is NOTHING: no counter, no shelves, no casks"
seven map-true houses look like seven barns footprint + tier say nothing about function the character pass (one emblem sign, the trade visible)
false glass "defects" a blanket no-glass rule glass by wealth tier
pseudo-script on books, signs, ledgers anything flat invites writing "every book is CLOSED"; signs are emblems only; corner and sign sweep
arch-shaped doors "filling the recess" "a rectangular door under the tympanum, which stays stone"
a sky sliver above a facade the prompt named the sky "no sky in view"
a window in an internal partition the prompt read it as exterior "that wall has no window"
a people-free view with people nothing said so the explicit people-free clause
a cleared wilderness trail in deep snow prompt alone cannot bury a walled path pre-bury the route pixels in IMAGE 1; class D gate
a hut becomes a horse and sledge "sledge-packed" name the hut in a lock; eye-check at 4x

Process

symptom cause fix
a lane's conclusion lost in the hand-off completion messages truncate write REPORT.md first; hand back the path; anything load-bearing in the first line
the same brief dispatched twice, rendered twice no check for a live sibling check the lane folder for a fresh REPORT first; re-verify, never re-render
a gate that rewards the wrong frame it measures persistence, not correctness name the absence in the prompt; crop the background by eye; do not let the gate pick
a number right, the story wrong the lane's interpretation unchecked verify the lane's interpretation, not just its numbers; run a known-bad control
spend out of control volume: 54-cell matrices x takes x re-rolls a Cost line per run; cut by volume, never by renderer
the GM's attention spent on review folders every gated set went to review canon-direct delivery; review only story-critical faces and permanent bakes