8.1 KiB
8.1 KiB
Failure modes and the fix that worked
Quick index. Each line: the symptom, the measured cause, the fix. Longer versions live in prompting.md, gates.md and matrices.md.
Geometry
| symptom | cause | fix |
|---|---|---|
| overview invents halls, towers, a church | at town scale each house is a few px; the plate barely constrains the renderer | invented-structure gate; closer camera; name the absent big things in the town block |
| wide view zoomed in 4-10 % | the renderer frames for legibility | FRAMING LOCK with band positions in % of frame |
| small town moved up toward the mountains behind a wide foreground | same | the explicit FOREGROUND sentence ("the town is SMALL and sits LOW, houses from 71 % to 96 %") |
| facade cropped by the plate restored to full height, with the tower | the renderer steps back to show the building | "every edge cuts the scene where image 1's edges cut it; the set-back story and tower are hidden from here" (0/3 -> 4/4) |
| castle redrawn as a palace at 3 km | prior for "castle" | landmark region correlation (0.16 vs 0.4-0.7) + "the castle stays small, not enlarged into a palace; no new towers, spires or domes" |
| mountain shrunk to fit its summit in frame | the plate's wall runs out the top edge | SKY_FIT column gate + "rises out of the top edge, no sky above them there" |
| snow on a low flank through a telephoto | prior for "alpine" | one edit-with-itself replacing white patches with rock; gate on snow-colored px below the snow line |
| verticals tilted 1-2.6 degrees, frame shrunk | a pitched-up plate | render level with a vertical lens shift |
| a feature on the wrong face | named in a shared feature list while occluded from this camera | per-camera visibility list; disown occluded features positively |
| a river or castle appears in a view facing away from it | the prompt's global landmark text | "there is NO river, NO lake, NO castle; they are behind the camera" |
| eleven gables where the map has four houses | touching quads in the massing | 4-7 px gaps, stepped fronts |
| ruins in the plate | footprint slivers | open with a 2 m disc, drop pieces under 40 m2 |
| a stone post with a ball finial by the road | a mannequin cut by the frame edge | proxies 10 m or more from the camera, off the edge |
| battlements across a roof | convex split of an L-wing with merlons on the internal seam | fix the edge list; check the untextured plate |
| a quay or wall runs to the frame edge | the model never said where it ends | model the far side as a different surface |
| a false lake beside the town | river class from a blurred floor level | take the river from the terrain's own water mask |
| the road in a trench | the road layer cut below grade | a broad shelf on a 1 m layer |
| a gate hidden in its own wall's shadow | the hour chosen for the plate | move the sun (16:00 instead of 16:30) and name the hour in the prompt |
People
| symptom | cause | fix |
|---|---|---|
| aerial figures 2.4-5 m tall | nobody set their size; the renderer sizes for legibility | proxies in the plate; the figure-bracket gate; shrink-in-place for legacy sets |
| near walkers +25-28 % | eye-level camera with no horizon relation | the EYELINE clause (eyes on the horizon line) |
| giants at a gate | no nearest-object relation | SIZES BY THE NEAREST OBJECT (adults reach half the palisade, a third of the posts) |
| a 1 m character at 1.4 m | a stated size is ignored | a contact relation the renderer has to draw (a hand flat on his hood, arm straight down) |
| extra lantern-carriers at night | the noun "lantern" | HEADCOUNT lock, lanterns carried by the same people |
| ghosts on quays and stair posts | "steam vents" | drop the steam clause |
| guests on the shut terrace | "2-3 guests on the balcony"; the noun beats the negation | state where everyone is as a positive fact; repeat the untrodden snow |
| a busy room with backs to the lens | packed density fills the foreground | NEAR-FOREGROUND and LOWER-RIGHT locks |
| a referenced man drawn twice | face reference + "lying" | exact headcount; "appears exactly ONCE ... the corner is EMPTY" |
| an outfit sheet's cowl on the wrong woman | a sheet attached without its wearer's face | describe the garment in prose; "she has NO brow ornament" |
| modern waistcoats, derbies, riveted aprons | "prosperous" + a plain garment noun | the period cut as construction facts; forbid the modern modes by name; a women's clause with no trousers |
| hip flips on side gear | "on the viewer's right" | "on HER own right hip" + "the back view is the same person turned round" (0 flips) |
| bloomers under a shift | the men's trouser clause reused on a woman | a women's clause: "hangs straight from the belt; lower legs bare" |
| a V sign | "two fingers raised" | drop the gesture; "no hand sign" |
| field sheds become people in deep snow | "tiny dark upright marks = townspeople" | a lock naming the sheds; eye-check open fields at 2x |
Surfaces and weather
| symptom | cause | fix |
|---|---|---|
| snow cell fails the gate 18/18 | a snow cap raises every surface ~4 px | thin fall "no deeper than a finger" for the calm cell; wall-band gate for storms |
| storm cells show a dusting | the thin-fall clause reused | storm prompt names snow in the air, loads, cornices, drifts; legibility clause outranks the storm |
| night heavy blizzard reads as a dark soft frame | wording cannot push a clear plate to a whiteout; contrast metrics misrank | veil-before-edit (deterministic veil from the depth plate), then "IMAGE 1 ALREADY SHOWS THE STORM AT FULL STRENGTH; keep visibility as low or lower"; silhouette gate |
| summer edit of a winter keeper adds ponds, drains channels, adds bridges | snowy low ground and snow-banked water look alike | pixel or guide lock; or build summer keepers from a summer plate; review water at 1-2x |
| a bright sunset glow in the east | the sky in frame is east; the sun is behind the camera | "THE SKY IN THIS PICTURE IS THE EASTERN SKY ... NO glow" |
| a sun disc in frame | the prompt named the sun without its position | "the sun is behind the camera; no sun disc" |
| a smoke plume from a building with no hearth | "chimney smoke rises" | a no-smoke clause for that building |
| the bar counter survives the "shut" state | "no counter" | "under the roof there is NOTHING: no counter, no shelves, no casks" |
| seven map-true houses look like seven barns | footprint + tier say nothing about function | the character pass (one emblem sign, the trade visible) |
| false glass "defects" | a blanket no-glass rule | glass by wealth tier |
| pseudo-script on books, signs, ledgers | anything flat invites writing | "every book is CLOSED"; signs are emblems only; corner and sign sweep |
| arch-shaped doors | "filling the recess" | "a rectangular door under the tympanum, which stays stone" |
| a sky sliver above a facade | the prompt named the sky | "no sky in view" |
| a window in an internal partition | the prompt read it as exterior | "that wall has no window" |
| a people-free view with people | nothing said so | the explicit people-free clause |
| a cleared wilderness trail in deep snow | prompt alone cannot bury a walled path | pre-bury the route pixels in IMAGE 1; class D gate |
| a hut becomes a horse and sledge | "sledge-packed" | name the hut in a lock; eye-check at 4x |
Process
| symptom | cause | fix |
|---|---|---|
| a lane's conclusion lost in the hand-off | completion messages truncate | write REPORT.md first; hand back the path; anything load-bearing in the first line |
| the same brief dispatched twice, rendered twice | no check for a live sibling | check the lane folder for a fresh REPORT first; re-verify, never re-render |
| a gate that rewards the wrong frame | it measures persistence, not correctness | name the absence in the prompt; crop the background by eye; do not let the gate pick |
| a number right, the story wrong | the lane's interpretation unchecked | verify the lane's interpretation, not just its numbers; run a known-bad control |
| spend out of control | volume: 54-cell matrices x takes x re-rolls | a Cost line per run; cut by volume, never by renderer |
| the GM's attention spent on review folders | every gated set went to review | canon-direct delivery; review only story-critical faces and permanent bakes |